Decisions on accepting, revising or rejecting a manuscript

The decision to accept, revise or reject an article is driven by the following rules:

The editors have the conclusive word on the acceptance or rejection of the paper. 

If both reviews are favourable (“Accept”), the final decision on acceptance is taken by the editors. Likewise, if both reviews are unfavourable (“Reject”), the final decision on rejection is taken by the editors. If both reviews suggest minor revisions (“Minor revisions required”), the author is invited to revise the manuscript, which is forwarded to the editors.

If both reviews suggest major revisions (“Resubmit for review”), the author is invited to revise the text, which is then sent for a new assessment either to the reviewers who raised the original objections, or to a third reviewer.

If one review is favourable and the other one unfavourable, the editor takes the decision about the following steps (rejecting or revising the text, asking a third reviewer to evaluate the piece). The reviewers have four weeks to submit their reviews, and editors have two weeks after having received the reviews to make their decision.

The author(s) will receive a Report to the Author(s). The editors immediately inform the author about the decision. The entire procedure should be completed within ten to sixteen weeks from receiving the manuscript, depending on the number of reviews required. The editors and the Editorial Board are not liable for any delays caused by reviewers. If an author does not complete the revisions within four months, the manuscript may be rejected.